If you need some help finding the best ice cream places in Indiana, we’ve featured 10 of them in the list below.
1. Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream
Based in Indianapolis, Sundae’s Homemade Ice Cream has been open since 1995. With over 25 years of experience, this store knows how to create delicious ice creams with fresh, local ingredients. Sundae’s multiple awards under its belt, this is an ice cream place you can trust.
Alongside traditional ice cream flavors, the team here offers a range of alternative options. From Key Lime Pie to Lemoreo, you can get creative with your scoops. Coffee and milkshakes are also available here to complement your ice cream. Also, this store is open every day of the week.
Find the team online here.
2. Crave Ice Cream Social
Looking for an independent Indianapolis-based ice cream place? Check out Crave Ice Cream Social today. This locally-owned store offers premium ice cream flavors and a wide range of toppings, allowing you to create your ideal cone.
With over 24 different ice cream flavors, all tastes are catered for here. Aside from ice creams, you can also opt for malts, sundaes, banana splits, and shakes too. Ice cream cakes can be pre-ordered, ideal for birthdays and private parties. Make sure you have sweet treats for your next event!
Contact the team online here.
3. Hartzell’s Ice Cream
Situated in Bloomington, Hartzell’s Ice Cream is a locally-owned shop with a community spirit. This ice cream place creates unique ice cream flavors for local residents, ensuring they can grab a sweet fix whenever needed. Hartzell’s is open from Monday to Sunday, there’s always a chance to stop by!
The Hartzell’s Ice Cream menu includes traditional ice cream, vegan ice creams, soft serve, frozen yogurt, carbolite, sundaes, spinners, parfaits, smoothies, slushies, and more. You’ll never run out of ice cream options with this extensive menu! Explore the menu online today to see more.
Visit the team online here.
4. PaddyShack Ice Cream
Based in Granger, PaddyShack Ice Cream is a family-run business with a focus on exciting ice cream flavors. This team strives to create a fun environment where local residents can enjoy a tasty ice cream cone. Whether you want a waffle cone or a cup, this store is here for you.
PaddyShake Ice Cream offers an extensive range of ice creams. Notable flavors include Fat Elvis, Caramel Chaos, Munchie Madness, Old Fashioned Vanilla, and Superman. Dairy-free ice cream options are available too. Milkshakes, cookie dough, and sundaes are also available.
Find the team online here.
5. Rocket Science Ice Cream
Are you interested in out-of-this-world ice cream? If you are, head to Rocket Science Ice Cream in Nappanee. This ice cream place offers ice cream with liquid nitrogen, a recipe that leaves a smooth texture and extra flavor like nothing you’ve tasted before!
On the menu at this location are over 20 unique ice cream flavors, plus dairy-free and sugar-free options too. You can also enjoy frappes, milk tea, lattes, coffees, and boba drinks too. Hotdogs are now available for those with a savory palate!
Contact the team online here.
6. Zaharakos
Located in Columbus, Zaharakos is a traditional 1900s themed ice cream parlor. If you’re looking for an authentic ice cream experience, this is the parlor to visit! With a museum room and an impressive menu, locals spend hours here enjoying the sweet treats and atmosphere.
Here you’ll find a range of homemade ice creams, in flavors such as raspberry chocolate, strawberry, and mint. Plus, you can try malts, ice cream sodas, and sundaes from old school recipes. Savory food and salads are also available here for a complete dining experience.
Visit the team online here.
7. Fundae’s Ice Cream & Sweets
Fundae’s Ice Cream & Sweets is an Indiana ice cream brand with two stores across the state. With locations in Speedway and Zionsville, this team is dedicated to producing yummy ice creams for local residents in-store and via catering at private events.
When you visit this team you can choose from a large range of flavors and desserts. Whether you opt for a pre-designed sundae or make your own cone or scoop, there are lots of ice creams to choose from. Cookie sandwiches, cakes, and cake pops are also available from this store. Perfect for anyone craving a sweet snack!
Find the team online here.
8. Cone + Crumb
This Westfield-based ice cream shop is dedicated to providing desserts to local residents. Since 2019 this store has been building their menu of ice creams, cakes, and slab pies. Ice cream fans can sample a range of flavors from Tuesday to Sunday.
Alongside in-store ice creams, Cone + Crumb offer ‘Ice Cream of the Month Club’, where subscribers receive craft ice cream flavors. From Kettle Corn to Blackberry Goat Cheese, these flavors are wild and wacky. This store also offers gluten-free desserts, vegan options, and catering.
Contact the team online here.
9. Berry Twist
Situated in Floyd Knobs, Berry Twist has been active in the local community since 1978. With 40 years of experience, this independent ice cream store knows how to put a smile on customers faces. Open every day of the week, Berry Twist is a must-visit for local ice cream lovers.
Key options from Berry Twist include soft serve, hardscoop, malts, sundaes, and shakes. Traditional flavors and seasonal options are available, alongside healthy yogurts and sorbets too. Combo meals and savory snacks can also be found here, ideal for a lunch time meal.
Visit the team online here.
10. The Old 27 Ice Cream Shop
Based in Decatur, The Old 27 Ice Cream Shop is a local favorite. This unique ice cream place is located on Highway 27, making it a popular pit stop for road trips and long journeys. However, locals make the journey just to take the 27 ice cream flavors!
The Old 27 Ice Cream Shop stocks soft serve, hard dip ice cream, frozen yogurt, sobetto, sugar-free ice cream, and sundaes. You can also order slushies and shakes for a cool drink. This location is open every day for local convenience.
Find the team online here.
