Do you need a handy selection of bagel shops in Indiana? We’ve featured 10 in the list below.
1. Bearded Bagel
Bearded Bagel started out on four wheels, and now they have their own store! Originally a food truck selling varieties of bagel sandwiches in Indianapolis, in 2021 they opened their first physical location in the city.
All of their bagels are steamed to create the perfect texture and then turned into your chosen sandwich. When it comes to picking what you want, there is plenty to choose from, including various types of meat with varying combinations of fillings, and even sweet bagel sandwich creations for dessert!
Head on over to Bearded Bagel.
2. Bagel Fair
Bagel Fair is situated in Indianapolis and first opened its doors in 1975. They are still family owned and run, now with the second generation taking the helm at their bakery. Although the shop opened over 45 years ago, their bagel recipe is a lot older, passed down through the family for over 100 years!
You can sample this tried and tested formula in one of their New York-style bagels, with different flavors to choose from such as apple cinnamon, poppyseed, and garlic. Either pair your bagel with a schmear of cream cheese or build your sandwich with a range of meats, cheeses, and other fillings.
Say hello to Bagel Fair.
3. 5th Street Coffee & Bagel
5th Street Coffee & Bagel can be found in Richmond. Their store merges together a range of different cultures and influences in their decor and menu, but one thing is for sure: coffee and bagels are at the heart of what they do!
All of their bagels are baked fresh every day in the store, and there is an assortment of flavors to choose from. Take your pick from a selection including maple, sun-dried tomato, blueberry, and lots more classic and unique varieties. Choose even a sweet or savory schmear of cream cheese, or check out their sandwich menu.
Reach out to 5th Street Coffee & Bagel.
4. Ripple Bagel & Deli
First set up in 2003, this family-owned bagel shop is operated by the second generation of the Richman family, with Ginny and Todd heading things up at the counter. You can find Ripple Bagel & Deli in Indianapolis, alongside their steamed bagel sandwiches.
You can either go for a classic flavor, such as an everything or an onion bagel or go for something more unusual like apple or sun-dried tomato. If you are feeling adventurous, or a little indecisive, leave yourself in Ripple Bagel & Deli’s capable hands and they’ll create a random sandwich for you with their “lottery” option!
Take a bite at Ripple Bagel & Deli.
5. Gable’s Bagels
Gable’s Bagels is the brainchild of Ed Schwarzman, who wanted to bring New York-style bagels and a slice of his hometown to the Midwest! Their kosher water bagels are baked fresh every day in Bloomington.
Try a rainbow bagel, with colors sure to stand out. If you fancy something a little less bright there are plenty of other options for you! Have your bagel made into a delicious sandwich or ply it with a schmear. If you want to experience Gable’s Bagels at home, then their take-and-bake offering means you can cook them up fresh whenever you need them!
Enquire with Gable’s Bagels.
6. Shop Two Sixty
You can find Shop Two Sixty in Fort Wayne, where they make their sourdough bagels in the traditional way, with every single one being freshly formed in-house, boiled, and then baked for the best taste and texture.
They have plenty of bagels, but they have more flavored schmears than you can shake a stick at! Enjoy cream cheese blended with flavors such as black garlic, cheddar horseradish, and spiced honey butter. To top it all off, they make sure to source as many things as they can from local producers, so you know every bite hasn’t traveled far to your plate!
Get in touch with Shop Two Sixty.
7. Bloomington Bagel Company
As you might expect from the name, you can find the Bloomington Bagel Company in the city of the same name! They are four locations dotted around Bloomington, but they all have one thing in common: serving freshly baked and boiled bagels!
There are plenty of bagels to choose from, and all but two of them are vegan! Once you have made your bagel choice, pair it with cream cheese, regular cheese, or veggies! If you don’t feel in the mood for a bagel, they also bake their own muffins, cookies, and scones.
Connect with Bloomington Bagel Company.
8. Einstein Bros Bagels
Einstein Bros Bagels can be found in multiple locations across Indiana, including a few stores in Indianapolis alone! The chain started in 1983, and it’s clear they are doing something right, as their bagels have led them to success all over the country!
With their bagels being baked fresh every single day, in batches every four hours, no matter when you stop by the store, you know you are getting the best experience possible. For an even better bagel experience, why not join their Schmear Society loyalty program?
Start a conversation with Einstein Bros Bagels.
9. Big Apple Bagels
Big Apple Bagels have been in business since 1993, with almost 30 years of bagel making under their belts, plus a whole host of stores across the country! In Indiana in particular you can find them in Fishers and Avon.
Every single bagel is baked in-house, whether you are joining them for breakfast or stopping by for lunch. With catering options to take away for larger gatherings or office lunches, you’re certain to find an option that works for you, colleagues, friends, or family!
Connect with Big Apple Bagels.
10. Rochester Bagel & Coffee House
Rochester Bagel & Coffee House pair together two of the best breakfast treats out there: a freshly baked bagel and a piping hot coffee! Locals and travelers alike have rave reviews for this Rochester-based business, and it is clear to see why!
Rochester Bagel & Coffee House have just as many coffee choices as they do their bagels! Separated into sweet and savory options, choose from flavors such as 3 cheese, coffee cake crunch, and caramel apple nut.
See what’s cooking at Rochester Bagel & Coffee House.
